• Breakfast

  • Buttermilk Biscuits, $3

    Baked fresh every morning with real buttermilk.

  • Fritatta Sandwich, $7

    Daily selection of veggie egg sandwich with melted cheese on sliced pullman bread

  • Homemade cookies and brownies, $2

    Lemon Ricotta Cookies to Chocolate Chip with Malden Sea Salt, we make all these and more.

  • Assorted Breakfast Pastries, $4

    From our favorite French Bakery. Croissants, Danish and more.

  • Homemade Brownies and Nutella Blondies, $2

    From Belgian chocolate brownies, to Nutella Nut Blondies,

  • Lemon Ricotta Cake, $3

    Homemade with fresh lemon curd and ricotta.


  • Ridgewood, $10

    gruyere, parma cotto, roasted tomatoes, homemade dijonaise

  • Crown Heights, $10

    herb chevre, homemade hummus, harissa mayo, seasonal house-made pickled vegetables

  • Hell's Kitchen, $10

    homemade peppaspread, sopressata, pepperoncini

  • Arthur Ave., $10

    smoked mozzarella, pepperoni, house-made tomato sauce, roasted tomato

  • Bedford Ave Grilled Cheese, $7

    Bedford Cheese Shop's signature blend of cheeses and spices

  • Gramercy, $10

    goat cheddar, roast turkey, peppadews, homemade aioli

  • Chelsea, $10

    chandoka cheddar, branston pickle, pickled onions

  • Northside, $10

    fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, fig jam

  • LES, $11

    alpha tolman, sugar cured ham, sauerkraut, homemade rémoulade

  • Sandwiches

  • Sandwich of the Day, $9

    It's the haley's comet of sandwiches. Check the board for the daily special.

  • Daily Grilled Cheese, $7

    Daily changing selection.


  • Rotating Assortment, $16/LB.

    A rotating assortment of deliciousness to dip things into or spread on stuff

Shipping Policy

Shipping Policy

Shipping cheese is not a walk in the park.  Because cheese is fragile and highly perishable it requires swift shipping and special attention.  For all of our shipping, we use either FedEx standard overnight, 2-day, or ground.  Due to the need for speed, shipping costs might be slightly higher than you were expecting, but this is simply so that the product can arrive at your doorstep in perfect condition.  Please read our shipping policy below, and if you have any further questions, feel free to email orders@bedfordcheeseshop.com or call us at (718) 599-7588.  Thanks!

Processing Your Shipment

When we receive your order, we require one day to process and prepare your shipment, and it will be shipped the following business day.

If you are shipping to a location within the shaded area on the map: You are eligible for ground delivery on all purchases. All products will arrive the next business day. We send out deliveries Monday through Thursday, with the exception of national holidays.

If you are shipping to a location outside the shaded area on the map: Unless you are ordering only grocery items, we recommend shipping your product using 2-day or standard overnight shipping.  If you choose to ship standard overnight, we send out deliveries Monday through Thursday.  If you choose to ship 2-day, we send out deliveries Monday through Wednesday.

Note: If you want to ship to multiple addresses, please complete each transaction separately. You can save your account information to avoid re-entering your billing information each time. 

Ordering Perishable Product

We are excited to share our cheeses with you, but when ordering perishable products through the mail, there are a couple of things to keep in mind.

If you are shipping perishable product to a location outside the shaded area on the map above, and you choose to ship 2-day, it may affect the condition in which your products arrive.  We will most likely choose firmer, more aged cheeses that will survive a longer travel time.  If your heart is set on softer, stinkier, or blue cheeses, we recommend choosing to ship standard overnight. Also, during warmer months we strongly suggest shipping your product via standard overnight.

One last note…

Sometimes, things come up.  It is the mail after all.  If you are unhappy with what you received from Bedford Cheese Shop, it is important to remember that we are not responsible for the following:

- Foul , rough, severe weather and/or “acts of god” (earthquakes, tsunamis, global pandemic, etc.)

- Incorrect shipping address

- Unopened shipments. Our boxes are clearly labeled “Perishable,” and while product is packed in insulated boxes with ice packs, any dairy product must be refrigerated upon receipt.

- No available recipient.  Please make sure that someone will be able to receive the delivery in a timely manner. Providing the recipient’s phone number is always helpful.